Justin Tadlock 1 year ago When Members redirects users to the login page with the Private Site option, it specifically checks if the user is logged in using the WordPress is_user_logged_in() function before doing the redirect. It’s literally one line of code and the only way to do this in WordPress. It sounds like your issue is possibly a cookie issue, which is outside the scope of the Members plugin itself. That could be coming from a number of places. What you’ll have to do is narrow things down by testing a few things. Browser testing: Give this a try on another browser. Make sure to clear any cookies you have for the site. If you’re still having trouble: Computer testing: Give this a try on another computer. If you’re still having trouble: Plugin/Theme testing: If switching browsers and computers doesn’t fix the issue, you most likely have some code in your theme or a third-party plugin that’s messing this up. I’d recommend deactivating all other plugins besides Members and switching to one of the default Twenty* themes. If that fixes the issue, reactivate them one at a time to find which is the culprit.